Expanding Their Sphere: Montana Women in Education Administration and Public Health

McClellan style saddle, c. 1905

Lucile Dyas used this lightweight McClellan style saddle to visit Lewis and Clark County schools during her superintendency in the 1910s. Both county school superintendents and public health nurses traveled great distances on poorly maintained roads. Montana Historical Society Collection, 2013.39.04 Gift of Donald Gunderson in memory of Lucile Dyas Topping

As mothers and homemakers, women have historically presided over child and family welfare. By extension, their purview has included education and healthcare. Before the mid-twentieth century, teaching and nursing were the socially acceptable occupations providing avenues for women to expand their influence in public affairs. Making the most of limited opportunities, many teachers and nurses became school superintendents or public health nurses. Often collaborating to achieve their goals, these leaders in education and community health significantly improved Montanans’ lives.

Montana’s women did not obtain full suffrage until 1914, but they had participated in school elections since the 1880s. In 1882, Helen Clarke and Alice Nichols became the first two women elected to public office in Montana, both of them as county school superintendents. Their duties included visiting schools, recommending necessary improvements to buildings and curricula, and creating teacher licensure exams. They also coordinated teacher institutes to advance teachers’ skills. By 1890, twelve of Montana’s sixteen county superintendents were women. Since that time, the majority of the state’s county superintendents have been women.

A makeshift doctor's office--probably in a school. A woman sits at a table (left.) Back left a female nurse holds a toddler while a male  doctor listens to his lungs with a stethoscope. Another woman holds a baby flat on a table, while a third woman  weights and measures a 3-4 year old on a doctor's scale. Two children sit in a rocking chair waiting.

Public health nurse Margaret Thomas (shown here circa 1925, back left) traveled throughout western Montana organizing well baby clinics, lecturing on nutrition, care of the sick, and sponsoring school health contests. MHS Photo Archives Lot 30 Box 2 Folder 9

Coinciding with the ascendance of women county superintendents was the rise of public health nurses. The Montana State Board of Health, formed in 1901, employed four field nurses in an effort to decrease high infant and maternal mortality rates and to curb the spread of infectious diseases. Serving a population spread across hundreds of square miles, these field nurses traveled extensively to educate the public about disease transmission, hygiene, nutrition, and infant care. “These women supervise the work of all nurses in their districts,” reported the director of the state’s Child Welfare Division. “In conjunction with the county superintendent of schools and women’s organizations, they … hold children’s health conferences in schools . . . and advise prospective mothers concerning the importance of securing medical supervision.” One of these field nurses, Henrietta Crockett, established the first infant health clinic on a Montana Indian reservation in 1925 and engaged tribal members in the public health campaign.

150WHM right to left Elizabeth, Clara, and Sophia Barker, c 1910

Elizabeth Barker (left, posed here with her sisters) was superintendent of Broadwater County Schools for three consecutive two-year terms, the first woman to serve in that position in Broadwater County. Barker, who taught first in small schools at Diamond City and Deep Creek and then for eight years in Townsend, was elected in 1910, despite running as a Republican in a primarily Democratic County. Photo courtesy Betty Akana

The goals of public health and education often intersected. Schools were essential to the success of public health efforts, because they were ideal locations for evaluating children’s health, counseling maturing girls, and holding vaccination drives. Although the federal Sheppard-Towner Act of 1920 provided limited funds for states to hire school nurses, public health nurses often filled this duty until statewide school funding improved. Their school visits coincided with well-baby clinics (often also held in schools), presentations on maternity care, and home health visits. Public health nurses supported superintendents’ crusades for indoor plumbing, adequate lighting, and better ventilation in schools. They also backed superintendents’ efforts to retain nurses in each district.

Many women who became educators or nurses did so because of the career limitations placed on them in other fields. “I learned that I wasn’t equal when I was thirteen years old,” recalled Virginia Kenyon. Excluded from the vocational agriculture courses offered to boys in the late 1920s, Kenyon decided to become a nurse. Then, after she completed nurse’s training in Great Falls, she took advantage of the 1935 Social Security Act to fund her education in public health nursing. During her twenty-one-year career in rural Montana, Kenyon observed the discrimination public health nurses faced. “I would like to have had physicians accept the nurses in the field for what they could do, and not fight them as they had! We just had a battle with them all the time!” Kenyon believed that male county physicians resented the challenges to their authority that public health nurses represented.

Newspaper article titled "Public Health Nurse Holds School Clinics." Text reads: "Miss Helen Brown, county superintendent of schools, and Miss Emma Oman, public health nurse, are holding a series of school clinics in the rural districts this week. Monday, Miss Brown visited the schools and Miss Oman conducted a clinic and examination of the children in schools south of Kremlin, having a meeting at the Half Way Coulie School, and Wednesday they held a meeting and visited the Cassidy school north of Havre. Miss Margaret Thomas, state health nurse, who has been here in conference with Miss Oman, compliments her work highly."

Public health nurses and county superintendents frequently worked together to improve children’s health. The Havre News Promoter, October 7, 1926: 3

Female county superintendents encountered similar resistance from male trustees, who often opposed reforms and seemed indifferent to the educational needs of children. Noting that trustees repeatedly failed to budget adequately for teachers, supplies, and schools, Dawson County superintendent Alice Cavanaugh declared in her annual report in 1890: “There is one thing we need in our country schools, and that is a more competent and energetic class of Trustees and Clerks who will look after the financial affairs of our districts.”

The wage gap between men and women in skilled professions reveals one of the most significant aspects of the gendered discrimination faced by female educators and nurses, who received 50 to 80 percent of what men earned. As late as 1949, public health nurses were among the lowest-paid professionals in the state.

Despite such difficulties, women superintendents and public health nurses made significant gains for the public and in their careers. The election of May Trumper as Montana’s first female State Superintendent of Public Instruction in 1916 began an era of statewide school reform. During her twelve-year tenure, Trumper instituted many of the reforms that women county superintendents had been recommending for decades: a 180-day school term statewide; better teacher training and more rigorous certificate exams; more school nurses; better teacher pay; vocational training programs in high schools; and the first statewide equalization of district funding. Since Trumper’s election nearly a century ago, all but one of Montana’s state superintendents have been women.

Henrietta Crockett, one of Montana’s first public health nurses, served on the Montana Tuberculosis Association for thirty years. Among her accomplishments was the construction of a medical wing dedicated to Native Americans at the state tuberculosis sanitarium in Galen, which had previously excluded American Indians. In 1949, tribal members presented her with a star quilt in recognition of her advocacy. Schlesinger Library on the History of Women in America, Radcliffe Institute, MC433-359-2

Henrietta Crockett, one of Montana’s first public health nurses, served on the Montana Tuberculosis Association for thirty years. Among her accomplishments was the construction of a medical wing dedicated to Native Americans at the state tuberculosis sanitarium in Galen, which had previously excluded American Indians. In 1949, tribal members presented her with a star quilt in recognition of her advocacy. Schlesinger Library on the History of Women in America, Radcliffe Institute, MC433-359-2

By 1950, Montana had one public health nurse for almost each of its fifty-six counties. Many became leaders in their field and influenced public health policies. Pioneering public health nurse Henrietta Crockett was also executive secretary for the Montana Tuberculosis Association and led the state’s efforts to eradicate that disease. Virginia Kenyon became the Public Health Division director for the State Board of Health and represented Montana’s nurses in state and national professional organizations.

Montana owes much of the improvements in education and public health to its women school superintendents and public health nurses. Their dedication to the well-being of children and communities stimulated important local and statewide accomplishments, including a decline in the spread of infectious diseases, significant reforms in public schools, and expanded educational and public health services throughout the state. LKF

 

Women made important contributions in other “caring professions” as well. Read Early Social Service Was Women’s Work to learn more.

Sources          

Bradley, Frances Sage. Biennial Report of the Child Welfare Division, Montana State Board of Health, for 1923-1924. Helena: State Board of Health, 1924.

“Child Health Council Formed Here Yesterday.” Helena Independent, February 19, 1929, 10.

“Community Schedule for State Health Nurse.” Daily Interlake. December 15, 1924, 1.

Gannon, John. First Annual Report of the Superintendent of Public Instruction of the State of Montana, for the Year Ending August 31, 1890. Helena: Journal Publishing, 1891.

Helton, Dorothy. “Henrietta Crockett Wing Will Be Dedicated at Ceremony Wednesday Morning.” Independent Record, August 14, 1952, 24.

Kenyon, Virginia. Interview by Therese Sullivan, November 5, 1984. OH 1834, Montana Historical Society Research Center, Helena.

McKinnon, L. C. “Dedicate Henrietta Crockett Indian Wing.” Milwaukee Road Magazine, December, 1952, 15.

Montana Legislative Services Division; Montana Historical Society; Montana Capitol Complex Advisory Council; Women’s Foundation of Montana. Celebrating Women Elected to Serve the State of Montana. Helena: Capitol Complex Advisory Council, 2009.

Montana Nurses’ Association Records, 1912-1987. MC 170, Montana Historical Society Research Center, Helena.

Paradise, Viola. “Maternity Care and the Welfare of Young Children in a Homesteading County in Montana.” Rural and Child Welfare Services No. 3, U.S. Department of Labor. Washington, D.C.: Government Printing Office. 1919.

“Public Health Nurse Holds School Clinics.” Havre News Promoter, October 7, 1926, 3.

One thought on “Expanding Their Sphere: Montana Women in Education Administration and Public Health

  1. Some amazing women have served as Superintendents in their counties–my favorites are Helen Clarke (what a story) and Margaretta Kleinschmidt (who served Chouteau County for something like 40 years!